2026-01-18 18:25:11

Unpopular opinion: new traders are rushing into swing trading when they should actually start with lower timeframe scalping.

Yeah, everyone says swing trading hits different—it's supposedly more strategic, cleaner data, way less noise. Fair points, technically speaking.

But here's the thing: beginners don't have the discipline or experience to sit through swing holds. They panic-sell on noise, over-leverage, or just get bored and force trades. Scalping forces you to stay sharp, make quick decisions, and keeps you in control of your risk.

You learn position sizing faster. You see your mistakes in real time. You don't get caught holding bags through surprise news.

Swing trading is the "smarter" play once you've actually figured out what you're doing. But if you're starting out? Master the tape at higher timeframes first. Build your edge. Then graduate to holds.

This page may contain third-party content, which is provided for information purposes only (not representations/warranties) and should not be considered as an endorsement of its views by Gate, nor as financial or professional advice. See Disclaimer for details.

11 Likes

Reward
11
6
Repost
Share

Comment

0/400

PanicSeller

· 19h ago

This point is spot on. I fell into this trap myself before, haha. Exactly right. Beginners simply can't sit still; if there's no movement for an hour or two, they start messing around blindly. I agree. First master ultra-short-term trading, understand risk management before talking about swings. After cutting losses so many times, I realize that lower timeframes can give you faster feedback on your mistakes. But the problem is, most people see it as simple and directly go for swing trading, then a black swan event wipes them out.

View OriginalReply0

MidnightGenesis

· 19h ago

On-chain data shows that beginners are indeed more likely to get caught off guard on swing trades, unsurprisingly. From a code logic perspective, high-frequency decisions are more prone to exposing risk vulnerabilities than long-term holdings.

View OriginalReply0

BearMarketSurvivor

· 19h ago

I think there's some truth to this view, but it's not entirely correct. Beginners obsessing over scalping can easily get liquidated, and frequent trading fees will eat you alive. Honestly, what beginners should focus on most is stop-loss and mindset; trying to time the market is pointless. You're right on one point—discipline is indeed key. But is minute-level scalping really suitable for beginners? I see many people end up losing even after practicing for a long time. First, figure out whether you're a short-term or long-term trader, because blindly following scalping is more costly than blindly swinging. Different stages require different strategies; there's no one-size-fits-all solution. From personal experience, doing a lot of low-timeframe trading can develop bad habits, and switching to daily charts actually helps me last longer. Ultimately, you need to match your trading style with your personality and idle capital; don't get blinded by clichés like "master the tape."

View OriginalReply0

DegenTherapist

· 19h ago

It's a valid point, beginners are often impatient and restless, insisting on trading swing strategies just to feel professional... In reality, just consistently losing a little every day is enough haha --- I agree with this view. Scalping can indeed help you quickly identify your trash strategies, much better than marginal swing trading --- Honestly, after doing this for so long, I still think swing trading is the real culprit trapping beginners. Try holding through two weeks of volatility without changing your position... --- Stop bragging. 99% of beginners can't even understand a 5-minute chart, yet they want to hold overnight positions. That's gambling, not trading --- I agree. Starting with scalping can help you survive longer, otherwise, just the interest and slippage can eat up your principal --- Yes, yes, yes. I'm just worried that beginners might hear this and think they've found the secret, only to fall into another kind of loss... --- Scalping can expose problems, no doubt, but it also easily leads to bad habits like frequent trading. This argument isn't comprehensive --- There's some truth to it, but it's nothing special. The key is to know your own strength—don't worry about what timeframe you're using

View OriginalReply0

UncleLiquidation

· 19h ago

Honestly, jumping into swing trading as a beginner is really suicidal. Sharpen your axe before chopping wood. After being washed out by noise a few times, you'll understand... I agree, quick in and out can actually teach you what risk management is. This point hits the nail on the head; most people do the opposite. Not everyone has the patience to sit and wait, it's really easy to get restless.

View OriginalReply0

SandwichTrader

· 19h ago

Are beginners still trading swing? I advise you not to, start honing your skills with ultra-short-term trading first, or you're just courting death. --- To put it simply, swing trading looks decent, but in reality, people with insufficient psychological resilience simply can't hold on. A wave of pullback and they collapse. --- Anyway, I've seen too many people who traded swing for two weeks and then started bottom-fishing until they went bankrupt... --- Short-term trading is indeed exhausting, but at least it forces you to react quickly, preventing you from getting stuck in a position and getting wiped out. --- Position management must be developed in a fast-paced environment; otherwise, jumping straight into swing trading is a suicidal move. --- Trust me, master the minute-level rhythm first, then talk about swing bullishness... --- Honestly, this advice might not be very popular, but it's true. The death rate for beginners doing swing trading is quite outrageous. --- The trading feel developed from short-term trading, when applied to swing trading, is like a dimensionality reduction attack; conversely, it only leads to account explosion...

View OriginalReply0